Why Training Fails
by:
Kevin Dwyer
If the objective of training is for people to apply that learning in the workplace and make an observable difference to an organisation's results, then almost all corporate training fails to achieve its objective and even fails to measure whether it achieved its objective.
In a 2000 study, the American Society for Training and Development (ASTD) reported that only 3% of training was measured at Kirkpatrick's “level 4” of training evaluation “results” where there is an impact on the organisation. In contrast, 95% of training was measured at “level 1” where the participants liked the training.
A further breakdown of the study revealed that 37% of training was measured at “level 2” where participants learnt the material and only 13% of training was measured at “level 3” where participants applied the learning in the workplace.
It is fair to assume that where there was no attempt to measure, there was a consequent high degree of failure to achieve significant change.
Most training dollars are wasted due to a few significant failures in developing training.
When training is not related to the organisation's objectives, strategies and management's day to day behaviour, training is ineffective in delivering the desired results. Generic “off the shelf” training which has not been designed for a specific purpose with people from a known organisation in mind may increase an individual's knowledge, but it does not increase their ability to apply the knowledge. Even if training is devised specifically for an organisation, it will still be ineffective when the training does not relate to the day to day life at the “coal face” of managers, supervisors and shop floor personnel.
Understanding the “coal face” before commencing training is the most important preparation a trainer can do. An organisation spending considerable money on training should insist on the trainer having that understanding. The first utterance by the trainer which results in a response from their audience, “That does not happen here” is the moment that the trainer begins to lose the trust of the audience. When trust is lost, so is value and significant parts of the audience stop listening and participating.
The worst part of it is that, most times, the response is silent and the trainer may well continue on unawares.
A further cause of wasted training dollars is the use of methods which are not designed to achieve the change in behaviour, skills or knowledge that is desired. For example, lecture style methods used to change behaviour are inappropriate as they are best used to transfer only knowledge. To change behaviour, the training is best to be of an experiential type and must be supported after the training is completed by coaching and a structure of formal and informal rewards.
If the method used to train is useful for achieving the required change theoretically, it is still at times inappropriate for the audience. For example, role plays are effective for improving skills as it allows participants to practise what they have learnt. However, if the participants are unlikely to be comfortable with role plays, then the method is still unlikely to be effective.
The most significant waste of training dollars however, rests with the lack of thought in determining what training is needed. Training is seen as a class room exercise rather than a combination of learning interventions, which in combination results in developing the change in behaviour, skills and knowledge required. The failure of mangers and supervisors to determine what needs to change and developing an intervention framework to achieve the change is common.
The failure of trainers to insist on finding out before completing their instructional design is more common.
Behavioural change needs personal coaching of the individual and support by a strong framework of goal setting and two-way feedback, if not 360 degree feedback. Skills development needs coaching of a different kind, one where the emphasis is on demonstration and practise. The practise needs to be in an environment where mistakes can be made and learnt from. Knowledge can be learnt from books, lectures and interactive CDs to name a few. But knowledge needs to be used in context to breed confidence. So training in knowledge must be quickly followed by the individual being placed in an environment where it is used.
The fact that training fails so often because of a lack of clearly understanding the changes we want to develop and developing a broader training intervention beyond the class room is bad. Combine it with the habit of many individuals in Fiji to treat training as a CV builder, absorbing little but the most basic understanding of what was being taught and a recipe for systemic low productivity is created as the blind lead the blind.
“Trained” individuals using the most basic of understanding learnt in a class room to make decisions, implement projects and manage their people have a false sense of competence which impacts far beyond the class room.
It is the responsibility of managers, supervisors and most importantly, the trainers, to make sure that training does not fail. Failure costs too much.
About the Author:
Kevin Dwyer is the founder of Change Factory. Change Factory helps organisations who do do not like their business outcomes to get better outcomes by changing people's behaviour. Businesses we help have greater clarity of purpose and ability to achieve their desired business outcomes. To learn more or see more articles visit
http://www.changefactory.com.au or email
No. of Times this article has been viewed :
1798
Most Recently Published HRM Articles as of
|
|
Five Keys to Promoting Positive Human Behaviour
by
Peter Nicholls
When could human behaviour be more positive than when a person is totally absorbed in a passionate interest for no other reason than its intrinsic enjoyment. Forty years of helping people develop highly positive interests have taught me five important principles to apply in the workplace.
|
Talent Integration Problem - Why Most Companies Hiring Retention Is Rate Less Than 50%
by
Tony Kubica
Are you ready to start increasing your top employee retention rate? Then check out these three reasons why most companies and organizations fail to hire and retain top talent.
|
Boost Employee Morale With an Employee Incentive Program
by
BMA Editorial Team B .
Is there a lull in your office? Are your employees not satisfied anymore with the way that you are manning the place? Good managers know from their own observations that employee attitude affects their work and eventually the company's output.
|
Build Bridges Not Walls - Employee Recognition
by
BMA Editorial Team B .
Regular, one-on-one assessments with your staff provide an efficient two-way forum with which to set and review realistic achievement targets, provide feedback on performance, and listen to and consider any problems employees may have.
|
Recruiting Planning Strategy
by
Roy Vera
The article covers a new way of finding qualified recruits for the medical staffing agency. The insight deals with recruiting, planning and strategy.
|
Caution: A War for Talent Mindset May Be Hazardous to Your Results
by
Wally Bock
A "War for Talent" mindset is supposed to be the key to success in today's tough business environment. Evidence suggests otherwise. Instead of waging a war for talent, you need to hire good people that fit your culture and pay attention to three important keys to success.
|
The 7 Reasons New Employees Fail
by
Ingrid Cliff
The 7 Reasons New Employees Fail and How To Fix It - Fast!
|
One Thing You Must Know About Employment Background Screening
by
Michael Gaul
Employment background screening is an important part of the hiring process, but before you get too far there's one thing you must know: There is a difference between ordering an “instant” criminal background check and ordering reports through a professional employment screening company.
|
Maturity is About Being True to Yourself
by
Peter Nicholls
Nature can teach us much about maturity in life and work. For a mature plant to keep growing vigorously, deadwood needs pruning so new energy can flow. If you're in your 50's its time to reconnect with your natural essence.
|
What role does human resource management play in a business?
by
anthony church
This article explains the role of the human resources function in the management of a business.
|
Save huge $$$$ by learning how to keep your most valuable employees.
|
|
5 Common Mistakes in Hiring
by
Minesh Baxi
Managers typically make some common mistakes in hiring that can be avoided...
|
Nine Tips for Cracking the Personality Code
by
Dana Borowka
Personality assessments can help you hire effectively, manage employees better and deal with difficult people. To help you screen personality tests and testing companies, this nine-point checklist can help you review assessment tools and support.
|
Preliminary Job Interview Question Guide
by
Kristi Ambrose
There are also available articles on these sites for a run down on what you should do at a job interview or what is expected of you. This is great for the people that don't know what to say, how to act, how to dress or how to answer all those really hard questions like; "Where do you see yourself in
|
How to be the Candidate that Employers Love
by
gwyneth holland
Why is CV presentation more important than content. How to create an effective CV that employers will love. Be more successful than other candidates with the same, or better, qualifications.
|
7 Tips to Prepare for the New NLRB
by
Pat Lynch
While there is little or nothing that individual employers can do to stop the anticipated shifts toward union-friendly rulings identified by Board Chair Wilma Liebman, there are legal and ethical actions you can take to mitigate any negative effects they may have on you and your employees.
|
|
Search for ebooks on Management & Business